This site is part of the superjer.com network

Buffy Reviews & Media by Mikejer
home
reviews
podcast
articles
links
discussion


BAD EGGS (2x12)

A review by Mikelangelo "MikeJer" Marinaro

Writer(s): Marti Noxon
Director: David Greenwalt
Quick Links

Review

I find this entire episode an amiable waste of time. There's a few good scenes in a horribly uninteresting, but surprisingly well-paced, main plot. This isn't a bad episode, it's just meaningless. The Gorch brothers don't add anything but some light Texan fun to the mix. An interesting digression, though, is that the little creatures that attach themselves to a host body remind me of the creatures from the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode called "Conspiracy" where this alien lifeform is taking over Starfleet Command by using similar creatures as here to control Starfleet Officers. Anyway...

The only things really worth mentioning, besides the many attractive shots of Buffy's cleavage, are the developing relationships. The Xander and Cordelia relationship is ridiculous. They can't keep making out in broom closets for very much longer before getting boring to watch. For now, though, there's still some amusement to be had. The Buffy and Angel relationship, though, is seriously heating up. Buffy says, "Angel, when I look into the future, a-a... all I see is you! All I want is you." They're all over each other here and you can tell that sex isn't far behind. It's also nice seeing Joyce slam her foot down on Buffy's seemingly bad behavior, even though it really doesn't do any good.

Angel asks Buffy, "So you don't think about the future?" She replies, "No." In the series finale, Chosen (7x22), Buffy shows that she's learned something over the years by saying, "I'm not really thinking that far ahead. That's kinda the point ... (calling after him) Angel. (he pauses) I do sometimes think that far ahead." She finally realizes she is still young and does not need a serious relationship any time soon. Buffy really doesn't understand this concept right now.

That's where all the fun ends though. The rest of the episode is filled with, well, simply nothing worth even mentioning except for the fact that now Cordelia of all people can knock Buffy out with one hit to the head. What in the heck is wrong with the writers!? This has become an annoying trend throughout this season and will be discussed further in the S2 review. So, that's about all there is to say about this one. This is definately the calm before the storm.


Minor Pros/Cons (+/-)
+  Willow instinctively wanting to partner with Xander on the egg project.
+  Good conversation between Joyce and Giles.
+  Cute bedroom window kissing at the end.
-  Slow, ridiculous, and meaningless ending. It is kind of amusing seeing Buffy covered in goo though.

Foreshadowing
  • The following dialog exchange really hints at the fact that Buffy will end up a single mother, which both foreshadows Dawn's introduction in Buffy vs. Dracula (5x01) and Joyce's death in The Body (5x16).

    WILLOW: Well, there were an uneven number of students,and you didn't show, so...
    BUFFY: I'm a single mother?
    XANDER: No man of her own.
    BUFFY: Do you know what this says about me? That I am doomed to lead my mother's life! How deeply scary is that?

Quotes
JOYCE:   A little responsibility is all I ask. Honestly, don't you ever think about anything besides boys and clothes?
BUFFY:   Saving the world from vampires?
JOYCE:   I swear, sometimes I don't know what goes on in your head.

XANDER:   Well, you know, it's the whole 'sex leads to responsibility' thing, which I personally don't get. You gotta take care of the egg. It's a baby. You gotta keep it safe and teach it Christian values.
WILLOW:   My egg is Jewish.
XANDER:   Then teach it that Dreidel song.

BUFFY:   Oh, I told you, that faux parenting gig we're doing at school. Like I'm really planning to have kids anytime soon.
ANGEL:   I wouldn't know. I don't... Well, you know, I, I can't.
BUFFY:   Oh. That's okay, um... I-I figured there were all sorts of things vampires couldn't do. You know, like work for the Telephone Company, or volunteer for the Red Cross, or... have little vampires.

Score
50 /100
D
Silly, useless plot. Poor execution of intended (if any) themes. No new important character development or insight. Offers no reason to bother rewatching it.

Awards
  • Least Important in S2

Screencaps




Comments (9)

1.Jack Chimney  Feb 4 2007
Nice to see that someone else noticed the rather stiking parallels between this episode and TNG's "Conspiracy." When I first watched this one that really jumped out and bit me in the face, so to speak.

2.robgnow  Apr 9 2007
I did like the short scene where Giles matter of factly throws a parasite on Joyce's neck. It was nicely creepy and his face looks so blank while he's doing it.

3.Latoya  May 13 2007
I really really shouldn't laught at this quote but I always do.

"I'm going to beat you like a redheaded stepchild."

Does it help that it is a evil vampire saying it? !!

4.Barbara  Jul 9 2007
In the middle of this episode when Buffy and Angel are kissing in the cemetary and then Angel says he'll hunt and she could go home, they start kissing again, and the shot goes over to a gravestone that says in loving memory. It didn't mean anything to me when I first watched it, but going back and knowing that Angel is going to lose his soul, I'd say that was foreshadowing that there love was going to come to an end.

5.buffyholic  Jul 25 2007
I am sorry, you may call me cheesy but I like this one. I know this is a very lame plot but it just feels like everyone is having fun(including me, having silly fun) and also is a good break from all the drama we`re going to have.

6.Andrew  Jan 9 2008
I'm another who liked this more than you. The ending was admittedly pretty weak. Yes, OK, the Wild West vampires added precisely nothing to the plot, leaving one somewhat confused about their purpose there. And yes, the whole thing was perhaps a little silly. But it's a fun episode to watch, and I couldn't really point to any bits I didn't like.
Oh, and the bit where Willow comes off the phone and a camera pans out to show the broken egg is pretty creepy.

7.wilpy1  Mar 24 2008
One of the worst episodes ever. The plot is left so open ended. What was the science teacher's motive for selling the eggs? Why was he evil? Why wasn't he dealt with? Is Joyce seriously that stupid to believe the gas leak contrivance? Why were Hector and his brother even there - what the hell did they add to anything?! Why were so many Buffy/Angel kissing scenes when these things could've been resolved or done better?

I mean, the plot premise itself was ridiculous and there was only so much you could do with it. The first act of the episode actually set it up quite well considering. But it's like Marti realised it was a load of crap a quarter of the way through, and just gave up. She could've made up for the lame plot by doing more with Buffy's responsibility, but no. It just plain sucked in the end. Second worst episode, only beaten by the hideous Wrecked, in my opinion.

8.siv  Jun 5 2008
I love buffy/angel makeout kisses.

9.Jaden  Jun 19 2008
wilpy1: so where the wild things are is a masterpiece is it?


Post a Comment
Name


(copy your comment in case of failure!)

Security Code
Security Code


Copyright © 2000-2008 SuperJer.com. All rights reserved.